Saylor Grove

Take a hike through history!

 

A driver winding north on Lincoln Drive along Wissahickon Creek in Philadelphia, PA will soon come to Historic RittenhouseTown on the left. After passing the stoplight there, the driver could easily miss the wooded grove on the right. Even if they noticed the grove, by continuing on Lincoln Drive they would not be able to see the picturesque pond hidden behind the trees. That would be a shame, for the pond is an artificial wetland in the vanguard of a bold new environmental movement. The site of the wetland and trees is known as Saylor Grove. For a tiny triangle of only three acres it has many stories to tell, beginning long before the innovative wetland was created.

The stories of Saylor Grove are stories of people’s relationship to nature. When Europeans arrived, they harnessed nature at Saylor Grove first by using water power and later by extracting rock for construction. After Philadelphia grew around Saylor Grove, the City created a park there for residents to enjoy nature for recreation. Now the City has moved beyond the conventional idea of a park by reshaping the land to create an artificial wetland that behaves much like a natural one. Striving to live in greater harmony with nature by reshaping it, the creators of the Saylor Grove wetland are environmental pioneers.

Four centuries, four stories

The Lenape people may have drunk from the creeks in Saylor Grove for hundreds of years. Though their stories are not recorded and they may have had no settlements in the Wissahickon Valley, Lenape people probably passed through the area.

When Europeans arrived at Saylor Grove, they recorded their stories over four centuries:

Soon after Europeans came to Philadelphia, William Rittenhouse established a paper mill on the Monoshone Creek near Saylor Grove. The first Rittenhouse mill, built in 1690, likely did not affect Saylor Grove.

After the first mill was destroyed by a flood, a second mill was built in 1703 with a different technology. It was an “overshot” mill and required a mill pond to supply water to the mill through a mill race. The mill pond was created where the Saylor Grove creeks flow into the Monoshone Creek. The pond is shown on the 1863 map above.

On the 1750 map below, Saylor Grove is nothing more than a blank space between the Rittenhouse paper mill and the buildings on Germantown Avenue. Neither the two small creeks that meet in Saylor Grove nor the mill pond where those creeks join the Monoshone Creek are shown on the map. Monoshone Creek is shown but not named. It was also known as Paper Mill Run, for obvious reasons.

Further down the Wissahickon was the Robeson mill, which still stands and now houses the Philadelphia Canoe Club. In 1750 a road named Wissahickon Road was located where Ridge Avenue now climbs into Roxborough.

In the 19th century, coal-fired steam mills were introduced. They proved more competitive than water-powered mills in part because they did not need to be located next to falling water. Freed from that constraint, they could be located on larger rivers where transportation of raw materials and finished goods was much more efficient. The water-powered mills declined and in the second half of the century they ceased operating.

Saylor Grove’s economic role shifted from supplying water for mills to supplying rock for construction. McKinney Quarry, located about 100 yards south of Saylor Grove, operated from approximately 1836 to 1912 supplying stone for the rapidly growing city. In this period, Philadelphia became one of the world’s leading industrial cities. From 1840 to 1890, the city’s population grew tenfold from under 100,000 to over a million.

Before Walnut Lane Bridge was opened in 1908, Rittenhouse Street was the main road connecting Germantown and Roxborough. It ran along the southeast edge of Saylor Grove, as shown on the 1863 map. The other road adjacent to Saylor Grove was Township Line Road, so named because it was the border between Roxborough and Germantown Townships. After the two townships were annexed by the City of Philadelphia in 1854, Township Line Road was renamed Wissahickon Avenue as it is known today.

At McKinney Quarry, workmen drilled into the rock to cut it loose from the ridge above Saylor Grove. Steam powered machinery cut it for curbstone and crushed it for road paving. As many as 75 workers toiled in the quarry. In 1894, the owner of the quarry, William McKinney, leased a house in Saylor Grove from the City. Located at 205 Rittenhouse Street, it was on the corner of Rittenhouse Street and Wissahickon Avenue.

While not directly in Saylor Grove, the quarry surely had a great effect on it. The noise, soot, and dust must have been overwhelming to anyone strolling alongside the banks of the creeks in Saylor Grove. Who would that be, strolling by the Saylor Grove creeks in the quarry era? Cornelius Weygandt, a schoolboy at Germantown Academy in the mid-1880s, spent many Friday afternoons in McKinney Quarry, collecting minerals, chimneying up the rockface and fishing for minnows in the pool at the bottom. He and his chums must have passed by Saylor Grove many of those afternoons.

Not everyone enjoyed the quarry as much as Cornelius. Mary Lovering, owner of 18 acres between Rittenhouse Street and School House Lane, sued the quarry in 1903 for removing her shade trees and littering her private lane.

A century after the quarry closed, a trail named after the quarry was built where the quarry once operated. In the 2010’s, Friends of the Wissahickon built the Quarry Trail, which begins directly across Rittenhouse Street from Saylor Grove. Repurposed for recreation, the steep slope of the quarry site is now home to a loop in the trail popular with mountain bikers.

Fairmount Park, 1889-present

While the quarry dominated the landscape at Saylor Grove in the second half of the 19th century, major changes were going on nearby. The Wissahickon Valley was added to the Fairmount Park system in 1868 and most of the water-powered mills were demolished in the following decades. At first Saylor Grove was not part of the park. In 1889, the park expanded to include Saylor Grove and the nearby site of the Rittenhouse mills.

This 1895 map shows the newly expanded park in green. The quarry was still in operation and owned by McKinney, who also leased the house in Saylor Grove at the corner of Rittenhouse Street and Wissahickon Avenue. With Germantown’s population growing, one of the creeks in Saylor Grove was diverted into a storm sewer. On this map the creek emerges–is “daylighted”–just southwest of Wissahickon Avenue.

The road shown parallel to the Monoshone Creek on this 1895 map may not have been built when the map was made. Lincoln Drive was built there a decade later, ushering in the 20th century.

With the completion of Lincoln Drive through Saylor Grove, the Grove became the traffic triangle that it is today. This 1910 map shows its current boundaries: Rittenhouse Street, Wissahickon Avenue, and Lincoln Drive.

William McKinney died in 1908. Soon thereafter his stone quarry was transferred to David McMahon, a local homebuilder. The quarry would soon be closed and added to the park. In 1922, the City bought the quarry property for $25,000.

City Beautiful Proposal, 1917

30 years after the park expanded to include Saylor Grove, some civic-minded Philadelphians were not pleased with the conditions there. The Germantown Independent-Gazette called the area “squalid and uninviting.” It was certainly very congested, as seen in this 1917 photo.

In the spirit of the “City Beautiful” movement, in 1917, the City’s Bureau of Surveys proposed to improve Saylor Grove. The idea was to create a traffic circle at Rittenhouse Street and Wissahickon Avenue. The circle would boast a bronze statue of David Rittenhouse on a concrete pedestal, in the style of the Civil War monuments in other parts of Fairmount Park. Rittenhouse was a descendent of the colonial mill-owning family and an astronomer who lived during the Revolutionary War period.

The monument to David Rittenhouse was never built. Yet around the same time, a more modest improvement was constructed: The Fisher Memorial Fountain.

Fisher Fountain

A public fountain at Saylor Grove quenched neighbors’ thirst for 40 years in the first half of the 20th century. It was part of a second wave of Philadelphia fountain building.

The first fountain movement was led by the Philadelphia Fountain Society founded In 1869. Those 19th century fountains–for people and animals–were motivated by a coalition of three forces in public opinion: 1) Temperance advocates who saw water as an alternative to stronger drink in taverns, 2) animal welfare advocates concerned with the wellbeing of horses and dogs, and 3) public health advocates who knew that public water at the time carried typhoid and killed thousands. By 1874, after only five years, the Society built 73 fountains.

In the 20th century, however, the need for fountains declined since horses were replaced by automobiles and the City water was filtered and chlorinated to reduce typhoid and other water-borne diseases.

The improved City water led to a new motivation for drinking fountains. While cleaner water was a blessing, many residents did not like the taste. As an alternative to the water piped to their homes, many residents preferred water from spring-fed fountains.

In 1917–the same year the David Rittenhouse monument was proposed–the Art Jury of the Fairmount Park Commission heard a proposal for a fountain at Saylor Grove. Rather than honoring an astronomer from the Revolutionary War era, the fountain would honor Abraham Fisher, who died in 1903 and left money in his will to build a fountain in Fairmount Park.

Was the water in Fisher Fountain safe to drink? In 1931 the Fairmount Park Commission planned to sample the water in all Fairmount Park springs bi-monthly, as in this 1940 photo. After a test in 1956, the Fisher Fountain was declared safe. A year later, however, on October 9, 1957 the Fairmount Park Commission ordered all 75 fountains in the park posted as “unsafe to drink.” This was based on a Board of Health inspection that found unacceptable levels of bacteria in the waters of 75 fountains. Fisher Fountain in Sayler Grove would never flow again.

Was the water more polluted in 1957 than it had been in 1917 or 1940? Perhaps not, but scientific knowledge and public health standards had both increased.

“Rittenhouse Meadow”–Horses, Police and People in the Park

In the 1920s, equestrians were prominent users of Saylor Grove, which was then called Rittenhouse Meadow. From there they rode along Wissahickon Creek, according to one 1927 account.

The Fairmount Park Guard, established in 1870, maintained one of their many guard houses in Saylor Grove. The Guards were merged into the Philadelphia Police Department in 1972.

The guard houses fell into disuse and disrepair. The one at Saylor Grove was restored in 2013 by the Fairmount Park Conservancy at a cost of $30,000. The Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia awarded Fairmount Park Conservancy a preservation award for this restoration.

In the 1950s, capital improvements were made in Saylor Grove which still exist today. In 1953, the three concrete paths leading from Rittenhouse Street to Fisher Fountain were built.

In 1978, a sculpture was installed in Saylor Grove to honor Ned Wolf, a civil rights lawyer who led West Mount Airy Neighbors and fought to maintain racial diversity in that neighborhood. The sculpture of Ned Wolf and his family hard at play was created by Peter Rockwell, son of the more famous Norman Rockwell.

Saylor Grove’s Namesake

Saylor Grove acquired its name after the death of Judge Harold D. Saylor in 1981. Judge Saylor was a strong advocate for Fairmount Park, serving on the Board of Friends of the Wissahickon for 50 years and on the Fairmount Park Commission for 30. In his obituary, the Philadelphia Inquirer gave him this high praise: “He stood steadfast against all efforts to use portions of the park for other purposes. He denounced anyone and everyone (including Mayor Rizzo in 1972) who would give in on an inch of park property.”

In the 20th century Saylor Grove was managed as most parks are–to give residents open space, natural beauty, and a place for recreation. Early in the 21st century, Saylor Grove became something different, a radical form of landscaping in the vanguard of the sustainability movement: Green stormwater infrastructure.

Not everyone liked the newfangled idea. In a 2005 letter to the editor, a neighborhood resident urged the City not to build the wetland. He praised Saylor Grove as “well maintained and not vandalized” with “native shade trees” and park benches.

Saylor Grove is similar to the projects in Philadelphia’s innovative 25 year plan to change the way the City manages stormwater. Known as “Green City, Clean Waters,” the plan aims to reduce stormwater pollution by creating green stormwater infrastructure (“GSI”) such as rain gardens and wetlands.

GSI decreases the volume and speed of stormwater that enters storm sewers by slowing the flow of surface water and increasing the amount of stormwater that infiltrates the earth. This has two benefits: With less sediment in the water that enters water treatment facilities, those facilities are more efficient. With less volume in the stormwater system, there are fewer “combined sewer overflow” events, when combined storm sewer/sanitary sewer pipes discharge untreated sewage into waterways.

The Saylor Grove project was completed in 2006, five years before the “Green City, Clean Waters” plan was officially launched. The project–a stellar example of GSI–is featured in the American Society of Landscape Architects “Stormwater Case Studies.”

To create the GSI at Saylor Grove, the City altered a section of storm sewer to “daylight” a creek that had been diverted into the storm sewer for 100 years.

The creek was then dammed to create a wetland. The daylit creek and dam are pictured below:

In daylighting the creek, the project re-created a natural feature last seen in Saylor Grove in the 19th century. In damming the creek, the project created an artificial wetland where one had never existed.

So while green stormwater infrastructure is in part “back to nature,” it is also artificial to balance the negative effect of impervious surfaces that cover most of the city. Paradoxically, the City created an artificial version of a natural feature to allow the city’s water system to operate in greater harmony with nature.

Maintaining the wetland

Like any landscaping project, the Saylor Grove wetland requires maintenance. Maintenance costs are high because the wetland is undersized for the size of the watershed that it drains. For a wetland to efficiently filter the sediment in the water that reaches it, a 1 acre wetland should drain 30-50 acres. In Saylor Grove, the 1 acre wetland drains a 156 acre watershed, so it is only 1/5th to 1/3rd of the optimal size. The Saylor Grove wetland is undersized because the entire site is only 3 acres and the City wanted space for trees and also wanted no risk that the wetland would undermine the roads that surround the site on all sides.

In its 16-year life the Saylor Grove wetland has been dredged twice to remove accumulated sediment. 10,000 cubic feet was removed in 2010 at a cost of $83,470. A second dredging was done in 2021. The cost is partly offset by selling dredged material for fertilizer.

In addition to City-funded efforts, citizen volunteers contribute to the maintenance of Saylor Grove. Friends of Saylor Grove is a conservation and education organization dedicated to protecting and preserving the Grove and the wetland. Friends of the Wissahickon works with Friends of Saylor Grove in support of its mission.

Is it worth it?

The Saylor Grove GSI project initially cost at least $600,000 and the ongoing maintenance will be considerable. One benefit of GSI is the removal of silt from the water passing through it. Downstream from Saylor Grove, water is pulled from the watershed at the Queen Lane treatment plant where it is treated to create drinking water. Removing silt upstream improves the efficiency of water treatment downstream.

Every year, 70 million gallons of water pass through Saylor Grove, which sounds like a lot until that volume is compared with the volume processed at Queen Lane–160 million gallons per day, or 800 times the volume that passes through Saylor Grove. So Saylor Grove has only a small impact on the City’s drinking water.

The Saylor Grove wetland has benefits beyond its effect on water quality. First there is the beauty of the place and the opportunity it offers for quiet contemplation. The wetland appeals to birders, nature lovers, and neighbors strolling through the area.

What the City did at Saylor Grove was pioneering. It gave the City valuable experience for larger GSI projects such as the terraced ponds along Wise’s Mill Road and others in the City’s “Green City, Clean Waters” plan.

Beyond its aesthetics and its effect on water quality, the most important benefit of the Saylor Grove wetland is its role as a pioneer in the movement for sustainability and ecological sensitivity. It is helping to move us toward an imagined future in which clean energy replaces fossil fuels, native plants replace invasives, pollinator meadows replace turf lawns, and wildlife migrates at will through corridors of green habitat.

In Saylor Grove’s past, humans harnessed nature there by using water power and extracting rock for construction. Later we created a park there for recreation. We are now entering a new phase, with an uncertain outcome, seeking to live in greater harmony with nature. The Saylor Grove wetland is a small but bold step in that direction.

by Dean Rosencranz

Sources

  • American Society of Landscape Architects. http://asla.org/stormwatercasestudies.aspx
  • Stormwater case #470.
  • Bartlett, Alexander, archivist, Germantown Historical Society, interview, May 19, 2022.
  • Brandt, Francis Burke, The Wissahickon Valley, 1927.
  • Contosta, David and Franklin, Carol, Metropolitan Paradise, 2010.
  • Germantown Independent Gazette, “Famous Quarries,” September 22, 1901.
  • Germantown Independent Gazette, “Considering Park Extension,” September 27, 1917.
  • Hass, Al, “Goose that Lays Golden Expo Egg Still Needs Roost,” Philadelphia Inquirer, January 20, 1972.
  • Historic aerial photographs https://historicaerials.com/
  • Historic maps http://philageohistory.org/
  • Howley, Richard, Philadelphia Water Department, interview, May 24, 2022.
  • Levine, Adam, Philadelphia Water Department historian, interview, May 27, 2022.
  • Maule, Bradley, “Of Monsters and Men: Philadelphia’s Rockwells” Hidden City, October 14, 2015 https://hiddencityphila.org/2015/10/of-monsters-and-men-philadelphias-rockwells/
  • Philadelphia Water Department, Saylor Grove Stormwater Treatment Wetland “Operation, Maintenance and Monitoring Report” May 2010.
  • Stuhlman, Theresa, Fairmount Park historian, Philadelphia Department of Parks and Recreation, interview, July 21, 2022.
  • Van Atta, Burr, “HD Saylor, Ex-judge, Park Devotee,” Philadelphia Inquirer, January 6, 1981.
  • Waygendt, Cornelius, Wissahickon Hills, 1930.
  • West, Sarah, Rediscovering the Wissahickon, 1993.

Check out this Google Map to explore this and other unique historical points of interest, and become acquainted with the many trailheads in Wissahickon Valley Park!

Explore more Wissahickon-related historic points of interest, stories, art, videos, games, and much more on our Virtual Valley!

You probably don’t need us to tell you how special Wissahickon Valley Park is. Its 2000+ acres provide habitat to wildlife, refuge & recreation to over a million visitors per year, and protect the drinking water for one-third of Philadelphians. The park can’t take care of itself, however. It needs responsible park users and stewards to keep this special place clean and sustainable for generations to come.

HELP US TAKE CARE OF THE PARK BY DONATING OR BECOMING A MEMBER,
OR BY VOLUNTEERING WITH US AT A FUTURE SERVICE DAY!